The only place on the island to get your favorite sweet treats, top end gifts and home decor under one roof. Pony Tails has exclusive and custom designed souvenirs, ornaments, gifts and home decor found nowhere else plus the largest candy selection on the Eastern Shore. Pony Tails famous Salt Water Taffy, handmade chocolates and creamery fudge round out the perfect shopping experience!For travelers who use our international travel planner, Chincoteague Island holidays become easier to arrange, with trips to the Pony Tails and other attractions mapped out and timetabled.
Pony Tails reviews
Great taffy and a great selection of chocolate. Store is fully stocked and very clean. Good selection of gifts.
Great taffy and a great selection of chocolate. Store is fully stocked and very clean. Good selection of gifts. more »
Amazing peanut butter fudge and taffy. Very clean store shelves were fully stocked very largecollectionofcandy and fudge. The staff was very friendly and fast. I highly recommend shopping here
This place is huge and has a wide array of candies, sweets, fudge, chocolates, and just about anything else to satisfy a sweet tooth! There is also a nice gift shoppe area in the store carrying various beach vacation theme gifts. The woman at the counter was one of the nicest people we met on our stay and was very courteous and friendly and gave my daughter a very sweet little gift while we were shopping in the store.
Plan your trip to Chincoteague Island
- Get a personalized tripA full day by day itinerary based on your preferences
- Customize itRefine your trip. We'll find the
best routes and schedules
- Manage itEverything in one place. Everyone on the same page.
Popular things to do in Chincoteague Island
Hidden gems in Chincoteague Island
Shopping in Chincoteague Island
Kid-friendly things to do in Chincoteague Island
Side trips from Chincoteague Island
Trips in Pony Tails by other users
27 days in New Jersey, Delaware & Maryland BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Atlantic City Ocean City Cape May Court House 31 days in Chincoteague Island BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Pony Tails SouthEast Expeditions Chincoteague National Wildlife Refuge 5 days in United States BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Wildwood Cape May Lewes 5 days in United States BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Wildwood Cape May Lewes 60 days in Virginia BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Alexandria Chincoteague Island Virginia Beach 21 days in Virginia BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Charlottesville Luray Fredericksburg