The only place on the island to get your favorite sweet treats, top end gifts and home decor under one roof. Pony Tails has exclusive and custom designed souvenirs, ornaments, gifts and home decor found nowhere else plus the largest candy selection on the Eastern Shore. Pony Tails famous Salt Water Taffy, handmade chocolates and creamery fudge round out the perfect shopping experience!For travelers who use our international travel planner, Chincoteague Island holidays become easier to arrange, with trips to the Pony Tails and other attractions mapped out and timetabled.
Pony Tails reviews
This is a nice little shop that has all kinds of candies and homemade fudge. They also carry jewelry, home decor items and souvenirs. We received a warm greeting when entering and the staff is... more »
First time visiting the Island this week and so happy I came across this little gem! Seriously the best taffy I’ve ever had! Tons of cute gifts and decor and delicious chocolates! I loaded up on taffy to take home with me but I don’t think it’s going last long because it’s soooo good! Will definitely be stopping back next time I visit!
OMG my S.O. told me about this place and how much he and his kids love it!! They have the best gummy sharks. This summer, I finally had the chance to see it for myself. Great candy selection. They also have gifts, toys, games, beauty products, and even Christmas decorations. Highly recommend if you are trying to spoil someone you love.
Plan your trip to Chincoteague Island
Get a personalized planA complete day-by-day itinerary
based on your preferences
Customize itRefine your plan. We'll find the
best routes and schedules
Manage itEverything in one place.
Everyone on the same page.
See all ›
Kid-friendly things to do in Chincoteague Island
Side trips from Chincoteague Island
Hidden gems in Chincoteague Island
Shopping in Chincoteague Island
Plans to Pony Tails by other users
31 days in Virginia BY A USER FROM CHINA July, kids, popular & hidden gems Preferences: July, kids Attraction style: Popular & hidden gems Pace: Medium 5 days in Chincoteague Island BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES May, popular sights Preferences: May Attraction style: Popular sights Pace: Medium 1 day in Chincoteague Island BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES September, popular sights Preferences: September Attraction style: Popular sights Pace: Medium 32 days in Virginia BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES October, popular sights Preferences: October Attraction style: Popular sights Pace: Medium 31 days in Virginia BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES August, popular sights Preferences: August Attraction style: Popular sights Pace: Medium 9 days in Coastal Virginia - Eastern Shore BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES November, popular sights Preferences: November Attraction style: Popular sights Pace: Medium