The Mystical Mermaid, Islamorada

#15 of 15 in Shopping in Islamorada
Gift & Specialty Shop · Hidden Gem · Shopping
The Mystical Mermaid is located in Islamorada. Make The Mystical Mermaid a centerpiece of your Islamorada vacation itinerary, and find what else is worth visiting using our Islamorada trip planner.
Create an itinerary including The Mystical Mermaid
© OpenMapTiles © OpenStreetMap contributors

The Mystical Mermaid reviews

Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor traveler rating
TripAdvisor traveler rating 4.0
18 reviews
  • I have not visited the store in a couple of years and it has moved to a much larger location just down the street. The lady who runs the place is very sweet and helpful. I have a friend in New Jersey....  more »
  • Reasonably priced T Shirts and lots of mermaid things. Cute store and staff was friendly. Would return  more »
  • So... Long story short... We are heading back home and in need to buy some type of souvenirs from the Keys. After passing place after place, pass this place, say to self "that looks interesting," proceed to make a u-turn and see what's inside. From the outside, you think it's a small place, actually no. It's a pretty big shop with items from many categories. They also have many local artist items to choose from. The prices all reasonable. And if you're in the mood (I wasn't) you can dress up like a mermaid and get a professional photo done. Great stop.
  • This was a great store! Loved all the original mermaid & other beach & nautical type items. It was my 1st stop in the area stores & the only one I really enjoyed. Full disclosure: I am a mermaid enthusiast:)

Plan your trip to Islamorada

  • Get a personalized trip
    A complete day by day itinerary
    based on your preferences
  • Customize it
    Refine your trip. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Manage it
    Everything in one place.
    Everyone on the same page.