Mystery Spot Antiques, Phoenicia

#2 of 7 in Things to do in Phoenicia
Flea Market · Hidden Gem · Mysterious Site
This Catskills' "shrine to clutter" occupies seven packed-to-the-rafters rooms in a former 1800's Main Street hotel in Phoenicia, NY in the Catskill Mountains. Mystery Spot Antiques is home to an amazing array of hand-picked vintage clothing, breakables, antiquarian art books, Rusticalia, mid-century lighting, tons of used records and found objects you won't find elsewhere, as well as anything else that catches artist/proprietress Laura Levine's honed eye. She regularly brings in antique and vintage treasures, armfuls of killer estate-fresh vintage clothing, and stacks of vintage vinyl from cool collections.

For eighteen seasons the Mystery Spot odditorium has been the "must-see" destination for treasure hunters, thrifters, fashionistas, record diggers, tourists, musicians, curiosity seekers, fashion designers, prop stylists, and even a famous face or two. Even when the shop is not open, customers are welcome to dig through the dollar record bins and famous "Yard Sale in a Box" on the front porch, with an honor box/money drop at your service.

Homer & Langley's Mystery Spot Antiques

72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464

(845) 688-7868

2019 Spring schedule: open Saturdays 11 - 6, Sundays 11 - 5 + holidays. Open Memorial Day and every Monday thereafter. Starting in late June we'll be open Thurs - Mon all summer-long through Labor Day.

Please "like" this page, follow us on Instagram @MysterySpotAntiques or sign up for our mailing list and you'll be the first to know about upcoming sales and announcements. (website) (blog)

@mysteryspotantiques (Instagram)

With our world travel planner, Phoenicia attractions like Mystery Spot Antiques can be center stage of your vacation plans, and you can find out about other attractions like it, unlike it, near it, and miles away.
Create an itinerary including Mystery Spot Antiques
© OpenMapTiles © OpenStreetMap contributors

Mystery Spot Antiques reviews

Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor traveler rating
TripAdvisor traveler rating 4.5
37 reviews
  • a few months ago, while booking our air b&b I googled "what to do in Phoenicia" and the Mystery Spot was the first thing to come up. Now ive done a bit of traveling and sometimes a place that looks...  more »
  • Whenever in Phoenicia, I bring my friends to the mystery Spot. They all have enjoyed it. They have a great selection of vintage clothing, records and much more.  more »
  • This place is a wonderland of beautifully curated clothing delightful oddities. It is so lovely to find authentic vintage clothes at reasonable prices. Laura is both knowledgable and super friendly, and she was able to guide me to unique pieces that suited both my style and my size. Several rooms of fabulousness (including vinyl, books, and linens) and great fun all around! Highly recommend
  • This store is a highlight of visiting Phoenicia. Quirky, fun and chock full of treasures. Groovy vintage clothes, vinyl and estate finds. Plus owner/artist/photographer Laura Levine sells some of her iconic rock and roll prints. A must.

Plan your trip to Phoenicia

  • Get a personalized trip
    A complete day by day itinerary
    based on your preferences
  • Customize it
    Refine your trip. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Manage it
    Everything in one place.
    Everyone on the same page.

Popular things to do in Phoenicia

Woodland Valley State Park
Duration: 2 hours
Specialty Museum
Empire State Railway Museum
Duration: 2 hours
Gift & Specialty Shop
The Nest Egg
Duration: 2 hours
Rail Tour
Rail Explorers
Duration: 1h 30 min

Side trips from Phoenicia

State Park
Minnewaska State Park Preserve Kerhonkson
Duration: 2 hours
Ski Area
Hunter Mountain Hunter
Duration: 2 hours
Ski Area
Windham Mountain Windham
Duration: 8 hours
Kaaterskill Falls Haines Falls
Duration: 2 hours