You have 2 trips in progress.   See all
Trip Planner:   USA  /  New York State  /  Long Island  /  Port Jefferson  /  Amazing Olive

Amazing Olive, Port Jefferson

4.9
#1 of 9 in Things to do in Port Jefferson
Gift & Specialty Shop · Hidden Gem · Shopping
Create an itinerary including Amazing Olive
Find a special ingredient that'll turn an average meal into a culinary delight at Amazing Olive, a family-owned gourmet shop with a big selection of premium olive oils and balsamic vinegars from around the world. The store also sells salts, herbs, rubs, bath products, gift baskets, and bags. If you're eager to taste your find on the spot, hop to the next-door pasta shop and grab a loaf of garlic bread or slice of cheese you can sprinkle with the oils you bought. Use our Port Jefferson journey builder site to visit Amazing Olive on your trip to Port Jefferson, and learn what else travelers and our writers recommend seeing nearby.
Create a full itinerary - for free!

Amazing Olive reviews

Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor traveler rating
TripAdvisor traveler rating 5.0
49 reviews
Google
4.9
TripAdvisor
  • This cute little shop had a wide variety of interesting-flavored olive oils and vinegars. You're able to sample everything, and it's a fun stop in the little village. Definitely stop by for some... 
    This cute little shop had a wide variety of interesting-flavored olive oils and vinegars. You're able to sample everything, and it's a fun stop in the little village. Definitely stop by for some...  more »
  • I went to an outdoor artist fair last weekend as well as a garlic festival this weekend. I tasted 2 different companies version of the basalmic vinegar. As you know from my reviews, I am extremely.....  more
    I went to an outdoor artist fair last weekend as well as a garlic festival this weekend. I tasted 2 different companies version of the basalmic vinegar. As you know from my reviews, I am extremely.....  more »
Google
  • Such a neat, beautiful little store placed on the Main Road. The store owner Candy was very friendly, polite and helpful. A must visit place. I’ve never seen such a large variety of olive oils in all kinds of mixes and variations 😍
  • We LOVE amazing olive. The first visit, I went with my mom and sister who are from out of town. We were greeted with a smile and told We could try as many as we would like. We tried a few and purchased a few as gifts. I asked about their custom labels knowing my boyfriend had a birthday coming up in a week. They said, no problem! It came out great! My second trip was to pick it up and purchase a gift certificate, knowing he would want to vote visit and try them himself! Today we made that trip, again for a 3rd time being greeted with a smile. We tried so many, spent a while and then purchased some fig balsamic, jalapeño white balsamic and a Tuscan olive oil. Plus a few tasting dishes. We are so excited to try each and every one of them and when we finish I'm sure we will be back for more. Great for gifts, wedding/baby showers, hosting, so many reasons to come visit.

Plan your trip to Port Jefferson

  • Get a personalized trip
    A full day by day itinerary based on your preferences
  • Customize it
    Refine your trip. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Manage it
    Everything in one place. Everyone on the same page.