Find a special ingredient that'll turn an average meal into a culinary delight at Amazing Olive, a family-owned gourmet shop with a big selection of premium olive oils and balsamic vinegars from around the world. The store also sells salts, herbs, rubs, bath products, gift baskets, and bags. If you're eager to taste your find on the spot, hop to the next-door pasta shop and grab a loaf of garlic bread or slice of cheese you can sprinkle with the oils you bought. Use our Port Jefferson journey builder site to visit Amazing Olive on your trip to Port Jefferson, and learn what else travelers and our writers recommend seeing nearby.
Amazing Olive reviews
This cute little shop had a wide variety of interesting-flavored olive oils and vinegars. You're able to sample everything, and it's a fun stop in the little village. Definitely stop by for some... more »
I went to an outdoor artist fair last weekend as well as a garlic festival this weekend. I tasted 2 different companies version of the basalmic vinegar. As you know from my reviews, I am extremely..... more »
Great little shop. Everyone was extremely helpful. Able to taste before you buy. Assorted flavored oils and vinegars available in different sizes. Also have the option to purchase bottle for party favors with customized pictures and lettering.
I get most of my supplements from here, the quality is superb.
Plan your trip to Port Jefferson
Get a personalized tripA complete day by day itinerary
based on your preferences
Customize itRefine your trip. We'll find the
best routes and schedules
Manage itEverything in one place.
Everyone on the same page.
Hidden gems in Port Jefferson
Side trips from Port Jefferson
Franklin D. Roosevelt Presidential Library and Museum
Duration: 1h 30 min
Trips to Amazing Olive by other users
1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Amazing Olive Captain Fish of Port Jefferson 15 days in New York City BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Frick Collection Horse-Drawn Carriage Tours Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum 10 days in Clearwater & Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Clearwater Port Jefferson 10 days in New York City BY A USER FROM COSTA RICA Madame Tussauds New York Central Park Fifth Avenue 9 days in Port Washington BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Square House Museum Lyndhurst Playland Park 1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES Avalon Park & Preserve Sunken Meadow State Park Maritime Explorium